New Years Tournament Judging Thread

Here we will say who won and why.





LoneSaiyan115 vs. mkidkap123


BG's Judging.

LoneSaiyan115:

Quality- 4/5. The quality is fine.

Beat Sync- 4/5. Good beat sync but some beats were hit when it wasn't needed. This leads to some cut scenes that were too fast.

Lyric Sync- 5/5. No problems here really.

Enjoyment- 3/5. Would've been 4/5 easily without the logo but it really brought my enjoyment down. Also some effects seemed a bit clunky.

Overall- 3.5/5. Solid vid. Less fades and effects and it would've been a 4 at the very least.

Collective Score- 18.5/25



D.A. (sorry I've been busy/lazy)

LoneSaiyan115:

Quality- 4/5- I really can't tell the difference between good quality and great quality.

Beat Sync- 5/5.- The beats were hit in the right places, what more can you ask for.

Lyric Sync- 4/5. BG gave you a crappy song, it's not your fault.

Enjoyment- 4/5. It would have been a five if I had seen the anime.

Overall- 4/5. I liked it, it branched out from your normal style.


----------------------------------------------------------------------

mkidkap123:

Quality- 4/5. The quality is fine.

Beat Sync- 3/5. Some of the scene switches were off beat. The crossfades were fine for the most part.

Lyric Sync- 3.5/5. Some great scene selections here but not nearly enough for a better score in this category.

Enjoyment- 3.5/5. There were great moments in this vid and I enjoyed the ending. However, too many weird scenes and random masking.

Overall- 2.5/5. An OK vid but it has quite a few flaws: Some scene hiccups, randomness, and a few other things.

Collective Score- 16.5/25


D.A.

Quality- 4/5. Seems like the quality category is a gimme.

Beat Sync- 4\5. Good, me likey.

Lyric Sync-4/5. The hook is where you shined, I feel.

Enjoyment-3/5. Little things sort of irked me. Maka standing up and then she is laying face down, Soul walking away and the next scene has him face to face with Maka. Things lkie that.

Overall-3.5/5. It seemed a bit choppy, the good parts were good, but the not so good parts were just that.


milkis13 vs. xNekoMusumex- Song: Waiting by Since October. *Winner* xNekoMusumex


OvertureAMV vs. imv3ryhungry


Mycathatesyou vs. XNickvhz14


Redxstryker vs. sleepwalkq


thekungfukid vs. ChainedEStudio- Song: Only As Serious As You Make It by ShinSight Trio. *Winner* ChainedEStudio


LoneSaiyan115 vs. mkidkap123- Song: Love Will Remain by Renegade Five. *Winner* Lonesaiyan115


Benbenjeezy vs. TankEngineMadman


TisLehwis vs. Kanuzot- Song: HeyHeyHey by Bannerhill. *Winner* TisLehwis


nosaint317 vs. shadowmysticwarrior

could you also post the song names so we can see how much people suffered XD

this was my song

Completed matches have songs now.



Edit: You can also upload your video to Youtube now if you like.

this should be stickied...or w/e so its easy to get to

xNekoMusumex wrote:

this should be stickied...or w/e so its easy to get to

donezo

LoneSaiyan115 wrote:

xNekoMusumex wrote:

this should be stickied...or w/e so its easy to get to

donezo

Gracias

milkis13 had to drop, Neko advances. Song info added.

heres my video for your enjoyment

http://www.animemusicvideos.org/members/members_videoinfo.php?v=180417

compbros wrote:

milkis13 had to drop, Neko advances. Song info added.

BAHHH HUMBUG X_X I sooo coulda been like..muwahaha and edited that full song then T_T...oh well. You guys still wanna judge mine anyways? Lol

oh heres my video..
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vKgnnQpZxoI
I'll also have it on the org... member name is xHyuugaHinatax

LoneSaiyan115 wrote:

heres my video for your enjoyment

http://www.animemusicvideos.org/members/members_videoinfo.php?v=180417

Wow that was actually really really good. For a self described "action editor", I think I enjoy your non action stuff the most

thekungfukid wrote:

LoneSaiyan115 wrote:

heres my video for your enjoyment

http://www.animemusicvideos.org/members/members_videoinfo.php?v=180417

Wow that was actually really really good. For a self described "action editor", I think I enjoy your non action stuff the most

Fuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuckkkkkkkkkkkkkkk No hahahahaha, this was like the hardest thing to edit for me

rofl oh gods XDDD life was hated XD

so what's going on with this guys

Ya, i wanna know who im going against in round 2, or did this tourny completely fail?

No some people just take forever or completely forget =/ and my editing is slowly failing as we speak XD

lol well I want them to remember.. I want that 100 bucks haha

Me too! Lol...but yeah i kinda want them to judge that video..just so i know personally what they thought...so i can improve in the next round..

Anybody talked to them ? lol maybe they lost that $100

thats what i was about to say kid XDD i think theyr just broke so keeping quiet.

Don't know if I ever shared this, it was my video for round 1
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7F2rziMnyNs